Blog: From Smoke to Solution: Advancing Black Carbon as a Regulatory Pollutant

The Case for Regulation

Due to its significant climate and health impacts, as well as its traceability to specific sources, black carbon is increasingly discussed as a potential regulatory pollutant.

Climate Impacts: Black carbon emissions are of concern due to their extremely high global warming potential: external page up to 5000 times greater than CO₂. Black carbon absorbs sunlight and heats the atmosphere, accelerating global warming. When deposited on ice and snow, it reduces their reflectivity, external page leading to quicker melting.

Health Impacts: These minute particles penetrate deep into the lungs and enter the bloodstream, exacerbating respiratory and cardiovascular diseases and increasing the risk of lung cancer. A specific form of PM_2.5, it is external page more toxic to human health than other types of PM_2.5 such as dust.

Source Identification: One reason why black carbon would be easier to regulate than other pollutants is our ability to external page pinpoint the source. Black carbon from fossil fuels and biomass can be distinguished by their optical properties, allowing for targeted reduction strategies. This capability enhances the effectiveness of emission reduction efforts, enabling evidence-based decisions to address the predominant sources.

Gaps in Global Monitoring: The case of Africa

Despite the significant climate and health impacts of black carbon, global monitoring efforts remain inadequate. While ambient black carbon monitoring is external page increasing in European countries, the United States, external page India and external page China, but Africa lags behind. Only a few countries, such as external page Ghana, external page Kenya, and external page Rwanda, have some ambient black carbon data, with the high cost of monitors being a major barrier to more extensive data collection.

Even PM_2.5, which was declared a regulatory pollutant in 1997 in the U.S., is still inadequately monitored in many African countries. Western Africa has approximately one reference-grade¹ PM_2.5 monitor per 10 million people, and the situation is even worse in Eastern Africa, with only external page one reference-grade monitor per 100 million people. Introducing black carbon as a regulatory pollutant would require substantial investment and infrastructure development to achieve effective monitoring across the continent.

Overcoming Cost Barriers: Innovating Affordable Solutions

Low-cost PM_2.5 monitors have expanded access to air quality data. We need similar advancements for black carbon monitoring. Developing hybrid networks that integrate low-cost monitors with reference-grade stations could enhance coverage and accuracy. Currently, what is considered cost-effective external page often exceeds 3000 USD. During my PhD research in external page Malawi, I utilized the external page microAeth^® MA200 monitor for personal exposure measurements, which, while less costly than other monitors, was still expensive for the low-income context. Each filter tape, costing approximately 100 USD, lasted only three days due to the high-concentration environment, underscoring the ongoing financial challenges in resource-limited settings.

Research efforts are crucial to developing affordable monitoring technology, particularly in regions like external page Asia and Africa that contribute 63% of global black carbon emissions. Current monitors, primarily designed for cleaner environments, are inadequate for high-emission areas; even after the initial investment, recurring costs such as filter tapes continue to pose challenges.

Navigating Ambient Concentrations: The Need for Standards

In external page Blantyre, Malawi, the average black carbon concentration was 3.85 μg/m³ in July-August 2023. Without established regulatory standards, interpreting such figures remains challenging. While black carbon monitoring has seen recent advancements, questions persist: Are these concentrations safe?

While no national or international air quality standards for black carbon exist yet, both the external page European Union and the external page World Health Organization have recognized its significant threats to health and climate. This acknowledgment suggests external page impending regulations on black carbon emissions and air quality standards.

Steps Forward

Effective black carbon regulation requires a multifaceted approach that includes technological, regulatory, and educational initiatives.

Develop Affordable Monitors: To make black carbon regulation feasible, affordable and reliable monitoring technology must be developed. Investment in research and the development of low-cost monitors is essential to facilitate widespread adoption.

Establish Clear Guidelines for Monitoring and Reporting: These guidelines should be internationally harmonized to ensure consistency and comparability of data. Additionally, proper limits for ambient concentrations need to be established to provide clear standards for assessing black carbon levels and their impacts.

Raise Awareness and Build Capacity: This includes training and resources for local authorities to implement and maintain monitoring networks.

Policy Integration:  Leveraging existing infrastructure and expertise from PM_2.5 monitoring could accelerate the implementation of black carbon regulations.

By addressing these key areas, we can enhance our ability to monitor, regulate, and reduce black carbon concentrations, ultimately improving air quality and public health.

About the author

external page Saloni Vijay is a PhD student in the Global Health Engineering group, ETH Zurich. She is currently focused on evaluating the environmental risks and health impacts of open trash burning, with a specific emphasis on black carbon concentrations in Blantyre, Malawi.

If you are interested in learning more about Saloni’s work on Black Carbon in Blantyre, feel free to write her an email at or on external page LinkedIn.

Saloni is giving a talk at the external page European Aerosol Conference, 2024 in August in Tampere, Finland, and attending the external page International Global Atmospheric Chemistry (IGAC) short course and conference, 2024 in September in Malaysia. If you are present at any of these events, please reach out and connect. She would love to hear about your work and share hers.